Obligatory disclaimer: real life sucks. So, let us talk
about something different for a change – the 2019 movie ‘Ad Astra’. Warning, we
are going to be talking about this movie at length, so today’s article will
have plenty of spoilers! …Starring Brad Pitt and a fine-supporting cast, AA is…
depressing as Hell, and makes some smart strategies by focusing on either
close-up shots of the manly profile of Mr. Pitt, the amazing eyelashes of Ms.
Negga, (which is one of the main reasons I went to watch AA, I admit), the hirsute
face of Mr. Jones and son – or it making wide, far-sweeping, panoramic shots of
space. Consequently, it manages to avoid the fact that its’ plot is rather
sinewy and sickly, metaphorically speaking – and where to begin?
First, with the range of emotions – there really is not any.
Mr. Pitt’s McBride-son, since he is the main character of AA – period, it is
all about him and his father, (played by Mr. Tommy Lee Jones, again), everyone
else are just passers-by in his life. No wonder that his wife, (played by Ms.
Taylor), has left him within the movie
framework and is barely there from the script’s P.O.V. – she’s superfluous, you
can replace her, say, by Ms. Negga’s character and the plot off AA will barely
be affected. In an age of political correctness, this sort of male-centrism
sounds kind of politically obtuse, but because it’s a space opera, no one seems
to give a damn, plus September 2019 has given us ‘Hustlers’, so everyone might
also be distracted by them too.
Back to emotions – there really are not any. None of the
main characters display any. Between AoS and ‘Preacher’, as an example, we know
that Ruth Negga can be very emotional, with a great range of facial features –
but here we do not see any. To Tommy Lee Jones’ credit, he makes his McBride-father
character sound like a major egotistical asshat without displaying any
emotions: he may be completely deranged, in a captain-Ahab-like manner, but his
face? About as emotionless as his son’s.
Moreover, this applies to the minor characters too. Finn’s
Stroud, Ortiz’s Rivas and Hamilton’s Vogel appear only in one scene at the
beginning, and this is it, yet they are have blank, featureless, emotionless
faces that the rest of the cast also has. Mr. Donald Sutherland tries to make
his character – Pruitt – to be more impressive, the heretic, but the good
colonel is written out of the story by the end of the first third of the movie.
That much for him.
…Actually, the good colonel’s character, (as in ‘movie
character’ suffers another flaw): there is no back-story for him. When Mr.
Sutherland first appears on screen, the audience may be distracted somewhat by
his attempts to give colonel Pruitt some facial expressions, (and he succeeds,
landing firmly in the ‘deranged owl’ territory of faces), but not enough not to
miss that Pruitt and McBride-son have history together. Indeed, as the movie
progresses, we learn that Pruitt and McBride-father have worked on the Lima
project together, and there was a falling-out, and things ended badly between
them. This is just a step in the process to make McBride-son realize that either
something has went very badly and very wrong for his father, or his father isn’t
the man that McBride-son always thought that he was – and that thought has
driven McBride-son hard enough into making him into the man that he became by
the beginning of the film.
However! None of the audience knows this, not immediately,
and even after they do, all they see is a complete stranger, approaching Pitt’s
McBride-son’s character and immediately hitting it off as the old friends that
they supposedly are. In actuality, all that Sutherland’s Pruitt-character does
is to give some cryptic info about McBride-father to McBride-son, as well as a
memory stick with more cryptic info. And then he gets seriously shot and
wounded by the space pirates on the Moon and was written out of the story.
Right. The space pirates. They were the random monster of
the Moon arc. Because McBride-father had been a semi-deranged sociopath with a
complete disregard for his fellow man, including his family and himself, but
was presented to everyone as a dashing explorer and hero, things have to be
very hush-hush for McBride-son to get to Neptune and retrieve him…only not. McBride-son
had been lied to, and the military top brass decided that it was important for
him not to know it, and that laid the seeds for the Martian portion of the
movie, and its’ conflict.
Pause. On Mars, this is where the human b-story of the movie
– McBride-son is going through the Solar System to discover the truth about his
father, while various human factors try to help and hinder him – are the strongest. There, he gets some proof that
his father is alive, but the military is cutting him out, because he has done
his part and can be removed. Ruth Negga’s character – Helen Lantos – helps him
get onto the rocket that goes after his father all the same… and it can be
noted that while Helen Lantos is as
bland and emotionless as McBride-son is, Ruth
Negga is a good enough actress that you can almost see some of her Raina
character fro, AoS shining through, as Lantos treats McBride-son not unlike how
Raina treated Grant Ward at the final episodes of AoS S1 – but we’re not going
there.
Instead, we are going off to Neptune. The remaining crew of
that space ship, Cepheus, were actually government’s assassins, sent to off
McBride-father, (and probably the son too), now that colonel Pruitt is out of commission
and can no longer handle any
McBrides. However, secondly, they are the most incompetent assassins,
McBride-son is able to kill them despite his best intentions, which is sad, and
firstly, there had been the Norwegian biostation in space. It sent out a mayday
signal, and the then-captain of Cepheus decided to go there. There was a
conflict with McBride-son, who wanted to get to Mars ASAP to continue to his
quest for his father, but the then-captain of Cepheus channeled his inner child
and told McBride-son very pointedly that this was his ship, so he’s the one who
decides what their actions will be, so McBride can either tell them what’s the
big rush to Mars is all about, or he can take over Cepheus and make all the
choices himself. On one hand, this makes no sense – the crew of Cepheus were
apparently in on the secret op – to find and destroy McBride-father, on the
other, it is pointless: McBride was never the one to shirk responsibility, as
the opening scenes of the movie showed: he put on a spacesuit and went forth to
fix the robotic arm on the space station that he was upon, even though it wasn’t
really his job, so the entire scene of getting McBride-son and the then-captain
onto Cepheus is just painful.
But then they got onto the biostation and its’ monkeys.
Monkeys come in all shapes, sizes and species, so some dumb-ass decided to use
some of Earth’s biggest monkeys in an enclosed environment – drills. At 70 cm
long, and weighing-in at about 50 kg, drills and their closest relatives the
mandrills, are some of the largest primates there is, second only to the great
apes in stature, but unlike them, and like their more distant baboon relatives,
these monkeys are armed with powerful jaws and long sharp teeth – and have
tempers to match.
…No, drills and mandrills are not baboons, though they are usually confused with them, ever
since TLK-94, where Rafiki – a mandrill – not only had a baboon-like tail, but
also ID’s himself as a baboon, (seriously, look it up on that video. It is
right when he meets the grown-up Simba for the first time). AA’s drills also
have them, as do the mandrills featured in the second Jumanji movie reboot. In
real life, they only have short tails, not really noticeable in all that fur.
Back to AA and its’ space opera. As it was said already,
some idiot decided to manage some of Earth’s biggest and strongest monkeys in
an enclosed space, even though monkeys are very good at escaping their
enclosures…which is why in real life, baboons, drills & mandrills aren’t really
used in labs; instead, it is their macaque cousins, (such as the rhesus
macaque), that are used there. Those primates aren’t as big and strong as the
baboons, drills & mandrills are, and their teeth aren’t as big and sharp,
but they can have ugly tempers, especially the sexual mature males – but where’s
the blood? Aside from some scratches on the walls, (and monkeys don’t have
claws, unlike big cats or bears, someone has really dropped the ball on their
zoology there), there’s no blood or corpses, except for the first captain of
Cepheus, who ran into the escaped monkeys on the space biostation and got his
face ripped off for his trouble, because, yes, drills and mandrills are big
enough and strong enough to do that – see above. So, why there aren’t more
corpses?
Because either this was some sort of a trap for McBride
after the moon pirate ambush failed, or it is a plot oversight. I am leaning
towards the latter, but, still, common sense? You are going into space in an
enclosed, closed, and self-sustaining space station, from which you cannot
readily escape – and you are taking some of Earth’s biggest, strongest, and
meanest monkeys with you. Obviously, there were some people alive long enough
to send-out the mayday signal received by Cepheus, so something went even
wronger after that – and it was the plot of AA.
Where were we? Oh yes, en route from Mars to Neptune. Some
reviewers have hinted pre-release of AA that there is going to be a twist in
the plot. After all the plot twists in MCU’s AoS, I was skeptical about this
development, and I was right. The plot twist, apparently, was Space-Com’s
turning onto the McBride family, as presented by three-slash-four of the most
incompetent assassins that I have ever seen in movies and/or TV series. Some
people point out that in this manner Roy’s journey mirrors his father’s – both men
leave a trail of corpses in their wake even though they don’t intentionally mean
to – but the way, for example, that Roy kills the assassins is really pitiful
and annoying. Sometimes, McBride-son is more than competent enough to survive a
crash alongside the crashing space station, to space-surf through the rings of
Neptune, or to use the nuclear explosion of his father’s Lima project to
jump-start his own journey home upon his now-battered space ship. However, when
it comes to dealing with his father…
Now, let us not deny: McBride-father, Clifford, is a grade-a
asshat, who abandoned his family, (namely, Roy and Roy’s mother, Clifford’s
wife), in pursuit of his dream, of finding extraterrestrial life. He failed. In
the world of AA, produced, co-written and directed by James Grey, there is no
life on other planets, humanity is alone. Frankly, it makes the world of AA
very depressing…which may be what Mr. Grey was planning all along, but we
digress. The point is that Roy is smart enough, and competent enough, to do the
above-mentioned feats of epic awesomeness and daring-do, yet he wasn’t smart
enough to realize that his father might need some sort of meds, or to be
subdued in some manner, or something, before they are going back home? Yes,
Clifford is crazy enough, (or sane enough?) to play along until they are
actually in space, after which he begins to fight his son tooth and claw, ready
to kill both of them until Roy submits and cuts Clifford lose and off into the
space he goes, where he has lived and killed and now will die. This very
depressing, but is also a metaphor – Clifford is an albatross on Roy’s neck
that needs to be cut loose for Roy to become a fully-rounded grown-up and get
over his trauma of neglect. Sophocles’ king Oedipus rolls his eyes and gives
Roy a Shirley Temple – lad, we have all been there, and you sure that your
missus isn’t (kind of) reminiscent of your late mum? Sometime between
concluding the Martian plot arc and starting the – Neptunian one, the movie’s
script have done a complete turnaround, and rather than making the
McBride-father a proper character, they reduced him to a plot device instead.
Roy came to Neptune to prevent his (former?) superiors from killing his father and
blowing up the Lima experiment – and he did just that on both counts. As far as
plot twists go, this one ranks right there among the worst ones of MCU, for
example, and we still have not hit upon one more very important plot hole.
Uranus. No, not ‘your anus’, be still my splitting sides,
ha-ha, but Uranus, the seventh planet from the Sun, the one right there in the
middle between Saturn and Neptune. Named after a figure in Greek mythology, the
grandfather of Zeus and Hera, Uranus has the third largest planetary radius and
the fourth largest planetary mass in the Solar System – a very notable planet,
put otherwise. AA mentions it zero times and it is not shown at all in the
entire movie, even though AA shows us some clear-cut shots of Jupiter and
Saturn, never mind Neptune, which is the backdrop for the movie’s final act.
What gives? It is a planet, so political correctness cannot be blamed for this
one, (it may meddle with all sorts of aspects of Western life, but astronomy?
Not so much), so I’m guessing that Mr. James Gray, who was making AA into the
movie that was completely Sad and Solemn and Serious just
couldn’t endure the thought that people in the audience will have involuntary
chuckles when they hear the word ‘Uranus’ and promptly refused to have anything
with the movie until the offending name, and the offending planet, were removed
from the script, period. Consequently, ‘Ad Astra’ takes place in some alternate
universe, where Earth is a part of Solar System that has no Uranus either
because it never been in the first place, (yes, the formation of the Solar
System and etc. during the Big Bang as we know it was touch and go during that
initial time period), or because humans have blown it up somehow. And before
you say that it’s impossible for our race slash species to blow up an entire
planet I can only say that a) we haven’t invented the right way to do it yet,
and b) we haven’t tried yet either, intentionally or otherwise. That said, if
in the world of AA humanity did manage to blow up Uranus to a point where not
even space/ice dust was left of it, (in real life, Uranus, just as Neptune, is
an ice giant, whereas Jupiter and Saturn are gas giants, and Pluto isn’t even a
planet anymore according to some sources), you would think that at some point
of the movie this would’ve come up, because, hey, it’s an entire planet!.. Anything else?
No, that is it, actually. AA is a movie that has no humor,
very little normal social interactions, is intentionally depressing as f- Hell,
and sometimes unintentionally bizarre. Characters have no back story, they come
and go in the great epic that is life and times of Roy McBride, just as they
did in an equally great epic that was the life and times of Clifford McBride,
an insane murderous fanatic and sociopath, (but hey! Product placement of
NatGeo magazines! Money talks, baby!), so by cutting his father loose,
literally and metaphorically, Roy now gets the chance to be his own man – a surprisingly
small and simple message for such a pretentious movie.
…This is it for now, see you all soon!